Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Supreme Court enjoys speculative arguments. Backlash was triggered by Alito’s most recent.

Supreme Court justices often use hypotheticals to test their theories and limits of a party’s argument. Case involved whether Christian graphic artist can’t create wedding website for same-sex couple. Justice Elena Kagan sounded incredulous: “It ‘may be an edge case’ meaning it could fall on either side, you’re not sure?”. Colorado Solicitor General Eric R. Olson was before the justices.